Review: Breaking Dawn – Stephenie Meyer

breaking dawn cover

Twilight #4

Bella Swan is finally marrying her vampire boyfriend Edward Cullen. Her father Charlie seems to be accepting this all the more, though he is still not thrilled. After the wedding, Bella and Edward take off to honeymoon on Isle Esme. Bella’s part of the deal was to marry Edward to have him turn her himself, and his deal was that they would sleep together only after they got married. They honeymoon is perfect, and Bella is more in love with Edward than ever, and her sexual conquest with him has actually made her want to stay human longer (!!!!). Edward cannot believe that it is all the convincing she needed. However, things change rapidly when Bella realises there is something wrong with her body. It is impossible, but she is sure she is pregnant. Carlisle insists that Bella and Edward return so that they can get rid of the baby to save her, but Bella gets hold of Rosalie, Edward’s sister, and asks for her protection.

The Cullens are furious when the newlywed couple returns and Rosalie automatically takes control of the situation, keeping everyone away from Bella. She will not let anyone harm the baby. Jacob Black, Bella’s werewolf best friend, is still smarting from the pain that he has been caused, and is furious that Bella and Edward are now married, and that Bella will soon be turned. Upon hearing that she is back in the country and having heard that she is deadly ill, he races off to the Cullens to kill Edward, and instead finds a pregnant Bella. He is sickened. His La Push pack refused that morning to strike against the Cullens for discarding the treaty between the vampires and werewolves by turning Bella, but when they hear that she is bearing some abomination, they decide that they want to kill the Cullens. Now Jacob is not a part of this plan, and refuses to follow Sam’s order, ultimately accepting his Alpha birthright of the pack and fleeing to warn the Cullens that the La Push pack might attack. Edward and Jacob cannot stand one another, but are working on the same side – protect Bella, they both love her.

It soon seems that the pregnancy is changing – after hearing the thoughts of the unborn baby, Edward finally supports Bella’s decision to have this baby, and they have a contingency plan to turn her right after she gives birth. Jacob is shattered and flees to the city, desperately seeking out the girl that he will imprint on, and finding nothing. Returning to the house, Bella goes into labour, and will need all the help she can get. Her baby girl, Renesmee, is born, and Edward struggles to turn Bella, while Jacob leaves the scene, intent on murdering the baby that killed Bella, and instead he imprints on her. Bella is finally turned, but it seems that the Cullens are never destined for peace.

How will Bella deal with the transformation? Will she still love Edward, or will she be ruled by the insatiable thirst for the first few years of her life before falling back into some form of love with him? Will Edward be able to deal with Bella’s change? What will happen due to Jacob imprinting on a hybrid creature, Edward and Bella’s daughter? How will the Cullens accept the new addition to their family? Will the powerful ruling vampires, the Volturi, finally leave the Cullens be now that Bella has been turned?

GRADE 4.5It’s over. Finally finished. So I can finally say that I have held up my end of the deal and read these four novels, but I have decided to disband the book club with my friend because I just can’t do something like this again. Breaking Dawn has quite a bad rap from the readers, and it is justifiable. The first half of it wasn’t too bad, but then it just peeved me endlessly. I think that the change from school and all that helped in some ways (I was so over reading about the classics and stupid school crap, all the while there was major lust for Edward going on), and the obsession, as bad as it still was, did not take front and centre stage anymore. I liked how Breaking Dawn was divided up into three parts, starting from Bella’s perspective, switching to Jacob’s perspective, and then flipping back to Bella. I was wondering whether this would be the case after Eclipse closed from Jacob’s point of view. At any rate, this book was so long, I must say. It is almost like it didn’t know where it was going for a long time, and there were moments where I felt the plot got convoluted and just went around and around in circles. Also, after this whole fancy wedding and all, I thought there would be some more passion between Edward and Bella, but I can honestly say I only felt more of that towards the end, after she finally got turned, and even then it was lacking (but still spicier than when they were in school). I was so glad that the story was told from Jacob’s perspective for the duration of her freakish pregnancy, I just don’t think I would have dealt with that if I had to read all of that as told by Bella. I mean can you imagine how disturbing and disgusting and annoying that might have become?! Ugh. Edward was certainly grating on me less and less now, it seems being a husband suited him more (again, he is such a dodgy love interest, and again this book harps on how you need kids and a husband to be fulfilled as a woman – meh). Let’s not even forget to mention how much Edward and Bella started banging after she was turned. I am stating this because they seemed utterly unconcerned about Renesmee or their parenting responsibilities. What the hell is up with their priorities?! I was also a little grossed out about Jacob imprinting on Renesmee. It was a little disconcerting for me – he was wildly in love with Bella and then it was all about Renesmee, and they just went back to being friends? Strange and just incredibly incestuous. Eeeeeeew. Not really the neatest way to tie things up there. Naturally there was more drama than you could shake a stick at in here, and everyone was on the brink of dying again and all that and wars were being prepared for, but oh well, I guess that is simply how this worked. ALSO, and I know this is a bit bizarre, but it always freaks me out when reading these things, I would love to know how a century-old dead thing gets a hard on, never mind the fact that the dead thing can somehow miraculously reproduce. It just freaks me out. It’s disgusting, is what. I can at least say that I have read all these books now, though I certainly don’t get the hype surrounding them whatsoever.

29 thoughts on “Review: Breaking Dawn – Stephenie Meyer

  1. I have to admit, I love breaking dawn better than the first 3 books. Breaking dawn is a lot more exciting than the others. I was really never a fan of Edward Cullen because Bella could have done a lot better by being with Jacob Black instead. But it is her choice on who she wants to be with. I always thought, why marry a vampire? There is another guy who wants to be with you, who never has just one look on his face like Edward always does.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. This was definitely more thrilling on one hand, and on the other it was just so much more of the same for me :/ The relationship with Edward and Bella completely evaded me, and while I liked Jacob more, he could also be super whiny. Edward, though, was just creepy and controlling and sulky ALL THE TIME.

      Liked by 2 people

      1. Exactly. Jacob was always whiny if she didn’t choose him, and Edward just gave off such a creepy vibe with his smiles and his blank stare he would have. I would have chosen Jacob if I was in Bellas shoes..

        Liked by 1 person

      2. I think he was the better (but overlooked) choice. Plus he made her laugh. Let’s be serious, that is more important than a perfect marble body. Which shouldn’t be able to reproduce.

        Liked by 3 people

      3. Yeah, but I still don’t see how it was possible for her to get pregnant….Because she really could have died with that baby in her. Plus its like in the movie her stomach kept growing like every couple minutes

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Renesmee is the kakkest name that has ever been bestowed on a child. It reminds me of this Afrikaans guy I dated who had a friend named Jacolette, named after her father, Jaco and her mother, Alet. But then again I have two great great aunts named Ossewania and Krugerina so I should keep my mouth shut

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I know, right?! Like you should be able to sue your parents over that. JACOLETTE?! O, die arme siel!

      You know what? You just won the bizarre name run. Hands down.


  3. This book was ridiculously dumb, but I’m proud that you made it through! I’m also happy for you that you don’t have to read any more of them. I love that the main conflict was a non-event, such lazy storytelling in favour of the stupid pregnancy narrative.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It was so daft! Why thank you, Anna! I think we need to make “I Made It Through Twilight” badges or something. Ugh, really, she made this whole thing that just fell flat. And then kicked us in the face with that end.


    1. Sheesh, what a nightmare hahaha! Hmmmm… I have a few book recommendations here, and I have a bee in my bonnet to read The Fault In Our Stars again. I am currently reading another book I was asked to review, and I am really not liking it :/ But these? I finished quite a while ago, and I have read some great books in between at least 😛

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Thank the Maker. Tis hard to dislodge Twilight from your head, I’m glad the healing process has already begun. You know, I still haven’t read The Fault In Our Stars. I know I should, and I really want to, but at the same time, I kind of don’t. I know it will make me cry.

        Was the book you were asked to review written by someone you know? Or was it recommended to you by a friend who absolutely loves it? Either way, can be awkward.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Ugh, what a mission!

        V, you have GOT to read that book! I love it and hate it because it was amazing but it was painful, but it is so worth the read! I know I sound like the ten million fans this book has, I also put off reading it for ages because of hype and because it was sad, but when I read it? No regrets. You should get a few super cool laughs as well!

        Nope, I was asked by somebody’s marketer/publisher/whatever to look into it and I have. Sometimes a recommendation can get awkward to review xD

        Liked by 1 person

  4. Zoe!! You survived the Twilight series!! You deserve a treat for that. Go buy yourself an ice cream or something. Hahaha. Yeah, I did appreciate the Jacob perspective, but Gawd that Renesmee shit…so awkward. Also, Renesmee could be the stupidest name of all time. And for as big as this book is, you’d think more stuff would actually, you know, HAPPEN. Lol. Well done, lady!!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Cara! I did! Can you believe it??? I was in shock for a while! Trust me, I treated myself to better books, movies, a life… it was amazing! 😉

      That Renesmee shit… when I heard that name I was like “Dear God, if you love the child whatsoever you wouldn’t do that to her!” – apparently it was acceptable though. Yuck.

      Seriously! I was like anytime it should be getting somewhere, and then NOTHING. Just like that. Pfffff.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I’m so, so happy to hear you were able to get past that shock phase. It can get you after that terrible ending…hahaha. Isn’t Renesmee the worst?? Like, I think I remember them considering something actually cute (Carlie?) and I was like that’s soooo much better! Why would you give your child a name that will probably get her made fun of in school?? Goddamn Bella…

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Probably get her made fun of? Definitely. I was also not a fan of the potential name if it was a guy (EJ – Edward Jacob; because things weren’t awkward enough). Ugh. These books.

        Liked by 1 person

Be bold, share your two cents!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.